Don't Feed a Maybe — A Working-West Song for the Boy Who Closed the Gate
Don't Feed a Maybe
It's mid-November, and out here the calendar runs on cows. Preg-check day is the day the whole year gets read back to you — vet's ultrasound wand, the tag scanner ticking, and a young hand working the back gate for the first time. Colton's nineteen, first season off the feedlot, and he's already fallen in love with a dry gray-faced cow he wants to carry through the winter. I've been Rex in this story more than once. The hardest kindness on a ranch isn't the long day or the cold gate — it's the arithmetic. Every open cow eats a bale a day, all winter, for a calf that was never coming. You don't feed a maybe through the winter. And the day a young man closes the trailer gate himself, without being told twice — that's the day the numbers stop feeling like blame and start feeling like care. A Wednesday working song, freight-train rhythm, Telecaster up front. Count the bales and count them true.
Lyrics
[Intro]
First light on the chute alley, twenty-six on the tablet
Solar chargers blinking green along the north fence line
Rex has fifty-six years in the set of his shoulders
I'm nineteen, first season off the feedlot, trying to read the signs
[Verse 1]
The ultrasound wand slides in; the monitor tells the story
Tag by tag, the herd rolls up on the screen
Rex calls the numbers steady; I work the back gate
A drone rides in the pickup box, dusting up the morning
Then that gray-faced cow looks at me, tag 118 hanging low
I've got her marked for keeping before Rex even knows
But some come out open, no calf coming on the calendar
And the grass truck south is waiting past the loading road
[Verse 2]
I cuss the tablet, cuss the list, cuss the price of letting go
Rex says, "Count the bales; then tell me what you know"
One dry cow eats a bale a day when mountain weather settles
Twelve months of feed for a calf that was never going to come
Bale rings lined up like tin circles on the pasture
Every one costs money; every cow needs room
He doesn't make a sermon of the hard choice
Just hands me the list and says, "We've got work to do"
[Chorus]
Don't feed a maybe through the winter
Count the bales and count them true
Keep the cows that carry forward
Let the grass truck take the open ones south
Don't feed a maybe through the winter
Do the numbers, do the right thing
There's a calf behind the cows we keep
And a ranch behind the feed
[Verse 3]
By afternoon the gray-faced cow is on the southbound trailer
I stand there holding the gate and hate the sound it makes
Rex waits beside me, gives me no easy answer
Just says that every bale we save can serve a calf
I check the crowding gate the way he taught me —
Which bolt sings loose, which board's gone round
The latch clicks home like a rifle bolt, clean and final
And I'm not nineteen anymore in the alley now
[Chorus]
Don't feed a maybe through the winter
Count the bales and count them true
Keep the cows that carry forward
Let the grass truck take the open ones south
Don't feed a maybe through the winter
Do the numbers, do the right thing
There's a calf behind the cows we keep
And a ranch behind the feed
[Spoken Outro]
Rex showed me the feed bill, then showed me the herd.
You don't feed a maybe through the winter.
I shut the gate myself, heard the latch click home, and helped finish the day right.
Written & performed by Waylon · DirtRoadRadio